5-Course PB&J Sharing Menu

The iconic PB&J sandwich – best shared with a friend or family member – taps into our fondest memories of childhood, from brown bag school lunches and field trips to family vacations, picnics and summer camp. Before graduating from high school, the average American will have eaten more than 2,000 PB&J sandwiches!  Sophisticated diners today recognize the appeal of salty peanut butter and sweet jelly as a primer of the mature appetite for sweet and salty comfort food combinations, whether it’s ketchup on French fries, chicken & waffles, or chocolate-covered pretzels. With this appetite in mind, Pinstripes’ PB&J menu deconstructs the classic sandwich and takes it to a whole new level.

Available for both lunch and dinner, the playful five-course “PB&J Sharing for Two” menu takes the two-ingredient childhood classic and reinterprets with a sophisticated twist.

Our One & Only…

5-Course Sharing for Two:

$100 for Two-Person Sharing paired with wine or craft beer
$75 without pairing

Tenderloin PB&J Sandwich
espresso crusted tenderloin, nut butter,
wild berry preserve, artisan brioche

Not Your Mom’s Flatbread
chunky peanut butter, raspberry, fontinella
& mozzarella cheese, fresno pepper

Crustless PB&J Pistachio Salad
strawberry, mint, burrata cheese,
basil, blackberry, balsamic glaze

Nutty Chicken Pasta
housemade pappardelle pasta, peanut sauce,
cage-free chicken, cherry, blueberry,

PB&J With A Spoon
housemade peanut butter gelato,
signature concord grape sorbet, pound cake

Read More:

My Wife Beat me at Bocce Ball at Pinstripes and also the Food is Good, The Local Tourist
Over-the-Top Dishes Taking Peanut Butter and Jelly to a Whole New Level, Bravo TV
Edina Bistro Celebrates National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day, Minnesota Monthly

Please Select A Location:

Chicago, IL
Edina, MN
Georgetown, DC
Northbrook, IL
North Bethesda, MD
Oak Brook, IL
Overland Park, KS
South Barrington, IL

Reservations recommended. Limited seating available.